I too tried the wild rose after really being happy with the hemp one. It does feel great at first, but dissipates quite quickly. It would be good for when I know I'm going to be washing my hands frequently, like at work or spending a day with kids, however the rose scent is quite strong and I'm concerned others around me might be bothered by it (particularly at work).
I have quite shaky hands and the shallow twist-on lid sometimes poses a problem for me (getting it back on properly). I can see this not being an issue for most, but something to think about for some people with arthritis or other hand challenges.
Glad I tried it, but I'll be going back to the hemp :)