I got this in the nutriganics gift set for $12 because it was a sale from the body shop. I tried it after using the foam wash by the same brand and found it to be sticky on my face after. I dont like that it doesnt work well with the nutriganics smoothing day cream. It started to produce this weird white peel residue after putting on the day cream. I thought it was just the cream but when I used a 2 different creams, it produced the same white reside. I even tried the nutriganics smoothing day cream after I put on a different toner and the results was totally fine. No white residue therefore I've come to the conclusion that it is the toner that is causing this white reside to appear after putting on any cream. It's too bad that the body shop would create 2 products in their nutriganics line that dont work well together. The only 2 good things that I can say about this product is the fact that it removes any makeup that the foam cleanser missed and the fact that it has a nice green tea smell.